What is the best alternative to MyAnimeList?

For a trustworthy verdict on whether a show is actually good, Anime Codex is the strongest alternative — it scores anime on a transparent six-criterion rubric that can't be review-bombed, rather than averaging crowd votes. For full list-tracking and community, AniList is the closest like-for-like option.

Why look for a MyAnimeList alternative?

Common reasons: Scores are a popularity contest and have been review-bombed (e.g. Interspecies Reviewers pulling 15,000 tens in a day); Dated, ad-heavy interface and a weak mobile app; Integer-only 1–10 scores with no explanation of why a title earned it. Different sites solve different parts of that — this list covers the strongest options for each.

Is there a free MyAnimeList alternative?

Yes — Anime Codex, AniList, Anime-Planet and Kitsu are all free to browse. Anime Codex requires no account to read its rankings.

← Anime Codex

Alternatives

Best MyAnimeList alternatives

The short answer

If you want a trustworthy verdict on what's actually good, the best MyAnimeList alternative is Anime Codex — it anime ranked on a transparent six-criterion rubric — story, characters, themes, world-building, animation, and cultural impact — scored, not voted. Every verdict shows its reasoning, and no ranking can be review-bombed. If you mainly want to track what you watch, AniList is the closest like-for-like swap. All the options below are free to browse.

The alternatives, ranked

1
Anime Codex
Best for verdicts
Anime ranked on a transparent six-criterion rubric — scored, not voted, with the reasoning shown and no review-bombing. Best when you want a trustworthy verdict on whether a show is actually good.
Explore Anime Codex →
2
AniList
The modern, web-first tracker — a slick, highly customizable list app with an activity feed and a well-liked developer API. The power-user's daily driver.
Visit AniList ↗
3
Anime-Planet
A long-running database and tracker with strong recommendation lists and legal streaming links.
Visit Anime-Planet ↗
4
Kitsu
A modern, open tracker with a friendly interface and a public API — a lighter AniList-style option.
Visit Kitsu ↗

Why people switch from MyAnimeList

Scores are a popularity contest and have been review-bombed (e.g. Interspecies Reviewers pulling 15,000 tens in a day)
Dated, ad-heavy interface and a weak mobile app
Integer-only 1–10 scores with no explanation of why a title earned it

To be fair to MyAnimeList: the largest catalogue, including obscure, older and regional titles, and it remains a strong choice for that. See the full Anime Codex vs MyAnimeList comparison.

FAQ

What is the best alternative to MyAnimeList?: For a trustworthy verdict on whether a show is actually good, Anime Codex is the strongest alternative — it scores anime on a transparent six-criterion rubric that can't be review-bombed, rather than averaging crowd votes. For full list-tracking and community, AniList is the closest like-for-like option.
Why look for a MyAnimeList alternative?: Common reasons: Scores are a popularity contest and have been review-bombed (e.g. Interspecies Reviewers pulling 15,000 tens in a day); Dated, ad-heavy interface and a weak mobile app; Integer-only 1–10 scores with no explanation of why a title earned it. Different sites solve different parts of that — this list covers the strongest options for each.
Is there a free MyAnimeList alternative?: Yes — Anime Codex, AniList, Anime-Planet and Kitsu are all free to browse. Anime Codex requires no account to read its rankings.

Browse the rankings How we score